Friday, 20 November 2026

Other Worlds and Shifting Carrier Bags: Revisiting Ursula K Le Guin's 1971 Book 'The Tombs of Atuan'

Jennifer Caroline Campbell explores the continuing relevance of 'The Tombs of Atuan’ and its relationship to Le Guins influential Essay ‘A Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction’ 

 

Ursula K Le Guin died in 2018 leaving an extensive body of writing, including 23 novels, 12 volumes of short stories and five essay collections. When she began her Earthsea series in 1968, she entered a largely male dominated arena of fantasy fiction, with stories populated by archetypal masculine characters and their similarly typical adventures. Le Guin’s Earthsea only partially departs from these conventions and in a gradual and nuanced way, which brought into question the dynamics that underpin these archetypes. For example, once you have fished reading all the books of Earthsea, dragons will never be the same again. 




In many ways The Tombs of Atuan, the second book in the Earthsea series, appears to sit compliantly within the established norms of the fantasy cannon of its time. A wizard, trained at a male-only wizard school, sets out to steal a magical treasure from a distant island and along the way attempts to rescue a priestess, whose role in many ways mirrors the princess archetype. But in Le Guin’s hands these all-to-familiar elements shift, changing and rewiring the recue-adventure trope, reconsidering who is rescuing who, what they are being rescued from and their relationship to where they are being rescued to. 

 

For this review I’m going to focus on the shifting of beliefs in the mind of the young priestess Arha, the protagonist of the Tombs of Atuan, as this particular shift feels enduringly relevant to the turbulent politics of our time.  As the story progresses Arha’s mindset moves from faith and obedience towards rebellion and escape. At the beginning of the story Arha seems unquestioningly committed to her assigned role as High Priestess of the Tombs. She appears to believe what she has been told about herself; that she is a reincarnation of the eternally reborn guardian of the tombs. This belief is part of a larger narrative that has been fed to her by various figures of authority who live with her in the Place of the Tombs. It is tied to a belief system that has warped over generations and in its current form works to maintain the empire and dominance of the God King. 

 

This oppressive narrative turns out to be something that Arha can chip away at. Her ability to see beyond the limits of these enforced beliefs stem in part from her encounter with the wizard Ged, the protagonist from the first book of Earthsea, who arrives in Arha’s world as a thief and enemy. Yet I want to argue that he is only one ingredient in a web of influences.

 

I have taken the structure for this web of influences from Le Guins essay The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction, in which she describes a novel as being like a container or medicine bundle ‘holding things in a particular powerful relation to one another’. Each of the ingredients in this web, or bundle, is unique and gains its power from the way it is arranged in relation to the other ingredients. It is this interconnected web of influences that produces something powerful enough to unlock the chains that confine Arha’s understanding of herself and her world. Each influence, or ingredient, reaches out of the story into our own world, offering up shimmering reflections of possible keys to the problems we face. 

 

I will now list the main ingredients that make up this carrier-bag-answer to the question of Arha’s shift towards rebellion. (These are only the ingredients I see; you might see others.)   

 

➳  

 

-‘๑’- Names

In most of Earthsea there are both ‘true names’ and ‘use names’, but this is not so in Arha’s land. However, she does experience a certain multiplicity of name. Sometimes she is called ‘The Eaten One’ and sometimes ‘Priestess’ or ‘Honey Comb’ (and later in the Earthsea series she takes other names). Most significantly, before she identified as Arha her name was Tenar, a name which the wizard Ged helps restore. Her old name, which is mentioned to her only once on her first day in the Place of the Tombs, is soon forgotten through lack of use. Yet it is still there in her subconscious, along with the understanding that a name, along with other things, can change.  

 

ੈ˚₊· Mother

Arha (then Tenar) had the misfortune of being born on the same night that the previous High Priestess died. This is why she was identified as the eternally reborn Priestess of The Tombs, selected as a baby and then taken from her parents at the age of five. Arha only remembers the colour and scent of her mother’s hair but she learns, via her guardian Manan, about her mother’s failed attempted at trickery; how she stained baby Tenar’s skin with berry juice to make her appear ill and therefore unsuitable. This attempt risked punishment and, although it failed, demonstrates bravery, love and disobedience.   

 

‧₊˚ '• Manan 

Manan is Arha’s loyal guardian within The Place of the Tombs and appears to genuinely care about her, providing sympathy and loyalty. At the same time, he is full of moral contradictions that feel ingrained and habitual. He often displays a chilling heartlessness towards others and exhibits fearful devotion to both the local gods and the rules of The Place of the Tombs. Yet at times he breaks those rules, especially when caring for Arha. 

Manan tells Arha about previously unmentioned pieces of history, prompting her to question the inevitability of the current arrangement. 

 

Arha appears to resent and despise Manan, yet at times she turns to him for comfort. Through her eyes he is abject and tragic, qualities that feel connected to the way his environment has shaped him. He provides Arha with an example of the horror of permanently submitting to the hierarchy of the Place of the Tombs and her potential stagnant future. Although it is Arha that is named The Eaten One, it could be argued that it is Manan who has been truly ‘eaten’ by the narrative sold to him. So, although Mannan always advises Arha not to rebel, his presence indirectly contributes to her growing doubt and disobedience. 

 

˚▓ Boredom/ Freedom.

‘Boredom grew so strong in her sometimes, that it felt like terror’. 

Ursula K Le Guin, The Tombs of Atuan


A double-edged boredom, of both too much and too little to do. Arha and the other Priestesses are kept busy,
preparing food, weaving, spinning, learning songs, rites, dances and the history of the gods. They get a small amount of time in the evening to play games, but Arha is soon moved to a separate living place, so is denied even this slither of unstructured play. This starvation makes her hungry for what she barely remembers. Her parents were forewarned that she would be taken away at the age of five. Because of this, I speculate that as soon as she could walk her parents gave her freedom to roam the fields and orchards surrounding their house, and that this early freedom planted a seed that lay dormant. 

 

ྀ ❥ ࿐Penthe

Below Arha in rank, Penthe is one of many young priestesses living at the Place of the Tombs, training for a life serving the lesser gods. She is gentle yet effortlessly rebellious and could be described as Arha’s only true companion within the Place of the Tombs. While Arha is recovering from the trauma of encountering three doomed prisoners, Penthe brings her some beautiful apples. These apples are lusciously described as pale gold and satin-like, with delicate brown leaves. While Penthe joyously eats three of them, Arha initially refuses the apples. It is only after Penthe makes her laugh by telling her a comical anecdote, that she allows herself to eat one. It is during this apple eating that Penthe affirms Arha’s secret doubting of the hierarchy of the God King, and more shocking to Arha, the possibility of unfaith in the local gods. These revelations initially make Arha deeply uncomfortable:

 

‘She had not realised how very different people were, how differently they saw life. She felt as if she had looked up and suddenly seen a whole new planet.’ 

Ursula K Le Guin, The Tombs of Atuan

 

°⭒˚ The Three Prisoners.

Arha cannot forget the three prisoners that she condemns to a slow death in the dark underground stench of the room of the chains, although she tells herself she can. She even tells herself that she will think up a crueller punishment for the next prisoners who arrive. Yet her dreams tell her something different. 

 

This cruel condemning of the prisoners’ fates, which Arha is provoked into authorising, could have bound her identity more tightly to her role as High Priestess and all that comes with it. Partaking in an inhumane act, even if coerced into it, can lead to a deepening of resistance to any doubting of the belief system that justified the act. This is because doing so would bring the distress of acknowledging the true horror of the act. The justification, even if unsound, becomes even more important. Yet for Arha, her condemnation of the three prisoners does not end up working this way. Instead, after some time has passed, it adds to the growing doubt in her mind. Why is this? 

 

Perhaps most obviously it is because she did not choose her position, did not work her way up to becoming High Priestess through ambition for power and status. There is another important aspect though, one initiated by a fleeting moment. When Arha first comes across the prisoners they are like ‘three heaps of something’, chained to the wall, in rags and without tongues to speak with. Every effort has been made to disguise their humanity and present them as ‘other’. At the same time, just enough detail is given so that the reader, along with Arha, is unable to look away from the horror of their dire situation. This is a great example of Le Guin’s mastery in describing states of unfreedom. Wherever it appears in Earthsea, the torment of unfreedom (from slavery and imprisonment to subtler forms) is brought vividly into the reader’s imagination. This is often done with just a couple of details. Though Arha’s eyes we notice the nightmarish claustrophobia of the Room of Chains, its smell, lack of light and the cruelty of the manacles. But the most vital observation for Arha happens in a brief moment, when she looks directly into the eyes of one of the prisoners and sees a glittering there.This momentary connection barely registers at first, but in the preceding days it creeps into her dreams and corrodes her faith.  

 

༊ ೋ  Maps/ Outside.

Earthsea is an archipelago with what is known as the Inner Lands towards the centre of the map and wilder places nearer the edges, where dragons fly and strangeness can be found. Arha’s homeland and the Place of the Tombs is positioned on an island towards the lesser-known outer edge of this archipelago. Yet to Arha, due to her isolated and inward-looking local culture, it is the Inner Lands of the Archipelago that are unknown, other and foreign. She mostly hears about this unknown world in stories that are designed to provoke fear. Yet despite their propagandistic intentions, these fragments and rumours contain glints that spark her curiosity. 

 

Arha’s awareness of these strange places beyond the sea, even when painted as demonic, tell her that if her current world were to crumble, there is somewhere beyond it. Even if she must become an outsider and loseeverything she knows, she understands that she would not be left without a world. The place beyond her familiar world is not a vacuum, but a mystery. Therefore, when Arha’s disenchantment with her surroundings grow, her thoughts quietly open to the possibility of enchantment elsewhere.  

➳

 

These ingredients jostle in the carrier bag, building their collective influence. The carrier bag that they share is the story of The Tombs of Atuan, a window onto an unreachable fantasy world. Yet, if I suspend my disbelief and take the world of Earthsea seriously I not only see refractions of my own reality in a new light but, like Arha, it shifts my understanding of the limits of my world. Encountering the radical otherness in Le Guins fiction exposes me to an outside, a beyond that loosens my current reality, making room for re-enchantment.  

 

‘Every time we look around ourselves and see things, mysterious in their uniqueness and wonderful in their difference, majestic just in their ‘being there’, and any time that we look at them and somehow fall in love with them – we realize that the disc of our world is itself an archipelago made of myriad discs. A world open to a radical ‘elsewhere’ both within and without.’

Federico Campagna Technic and Magic: The Reconstruction of Reality ( 2018) 

 


For more of my thoughts on The Tombs of Atuan, and printed reproductions Le Guin's maps from the book (thanks to the generosity of Special Collections and University Archives, University of Oregon Libraries) don’t miss Garageland 25 ‘Enchantment’. 

 

Special thanks to Cathy Lomax, Rowan Calloway, Julliet van der Velden, Nikki Campbell, Dave Prosser and Anne Campbell who helped edit both this review and its sister article in Garageland Magazine. It takes a village!